Chapter 138: The United Front Effect
Cao Hong did not understand how he could be of any help in absorbing the million refugees following the Yellow Turban rebels, but since Cao Cao had spoken, Cao Hong could only give one reply: "I shall follow your instructions, Elder Brother."
Cao Cao smiled and said, "Since ancient times, there has been talk of vertical alliance and horizontal strategy. Su Qin, Zhang Yi, and Gongsun Yan were all masters of this craft. A tongue of three inches could rival a million heroic troops. Today, if your brother wishes to acquire these million 'People of the Yellow Sky', I must employ the method of the horizontal strategy."
Cao Hong did not know much about vertical alliances and horizontal strategies, but the memories carried within his current body possessed a fair understanding of them. The so-called vertical and horizontal strategies were simply diplomatic tactics utilizing eloquent persuasion to unite various factions, bearing a slight resemblance to modern international pacts. The reason Cao Hong's original self was familiar with these strategies was not because he loved reading military books, but because the sharpness of the tongue was exceptionally important in business. In former years, Cao Hong's enterprises spanned across Yangzhou, so the arts of vertical alliance and horizontal strategy were disciplines one could neither afford to ignore nor fail to practice.
When Cao Cao stated he would use the horizontal strategy rather than the vertical alliance, his meaning was quite clear. The horizontal strategy involved a stronger power drawing in weaker powers to attack a rival force, whereas a vertical alliance consisted of a group of weaker powers uniting to resist a stronger power. To put it bluntly, Cao Cao now wanted Cao Hong to persuade a weaker faction to assist the Cao army in absorbing the Qingzhou and Xuzhou Yellow Turbans. As for which faction that might be, Cao Hong could not yet guess.
Hearing this, Cao Hong replied, "Back in the Warring States period, the State of Qin was powerful. Su Qin lobbied the six states of Zhao, Yan, Han, Wei, Chu, and Qi to form an alliance against Qin. Qin lay in the west, and the territories of the six states connected from north to south, hence it was called the vertical alliance. In response, Qin dispatched Zhang Yi to counter this by lobbying neighboring countries to submit to Qin for their own preservation, thereby isolating the states and defeating them one by one. This tactic was devised in direct opposition to the vertical alliance, which is why it is called the horizontal strategy. Today, if Elder Brother wishes to implement the horizontal strategy, our army is the State of Qin, and younger brother is Zhang Yi. I only wonder which minor state I am to lobby?"
Cao Cao laughed and said, "Among our entire Cao clan, you, Zilian, are the most well-versed in the matters of vertical and horizontal strategies; otherwise, you would never have established such a foundation in Yangzhou. Yet, your brother had never seen Zilian display these skills. Only now, upon hearing your classical analogy, do I realize your mastery of the way of alliances. Zilian, you should be the foremost person in our Cao family, and knowing this sets my mind much more at ease. After all, the person you must go to lobby has a fierce reputation, and you have never met him before. Although this man's forces are entrenched in Yanzhou, and our army's prestige has risen greatly, he will harbor a threefold wariness; yet to make him obey every command will be somewhat difficult."
Upon hearing Cao Cao finish his praise only to express worry, Cao Hong knew this matter would not be easily handled. Thus, he asked, "Please enlighten me, Elder Brother, who is this person?"
Cao Cao answered, "This man is also a rebel of Yanzhou, who styles himself the Mount Tai Banner Commander, Zang Ba."
Zang Ba... Cao Hong recognized this name. In history, this man was a formidable general under Cao Cao's command, yet right now he was merely a rebel? And a Mount Tai rebel in Yanzhou at that? Over the past two years, Cao Hong had heard the name of the Mount Tai rebels countless times. Ever since the Black Mountain bandits moved south, the Mount Tai rebels had seized the chaos to pillage Yanzhou. The current reality of Yanzhou—where lands lacked steady masters and the populace had no fixed homes—owed much to the efforts of the Mount Tai rebels. Moreover, on his expedition from Xiangyi to Dongjun, Cao Hong had slain several scattered bands of Mount Tai rebels. That was during the winter of the year before last, and according to those bandits, the main force of the Mount Tai rebels had already retreated to their old lair in Mount Tai Commandery to spend the winter long before.
That being the case, the Cao army and Zang Ba could be considered to have accumulated grievances. Now, Cao Cao had defeated the three hundred thousand Qingzhou and Xuzhou Yellow Turbans, his prestige was soaring, and he had even been welcomed by Liu Yao, the younger brother of the former Inspector Liu Dai, as the Governor of Yanzhou. The title of master of Yanzhou was well-deserved. Even if various factions across Yanzhou were unconvinced in their hearts, they had to weigh whether they possessed the qualifications to challenge him. Under such circumstances, sending men to demand that local factions cooperate in suppressing rebels should have posed no problem.
Yet that was only true for local officials and aristocratic clans of Yanzhou. For a major rebel within Yanzhou like Zang Ba, it was far from certain. This was no different from bargaining with a tiger for its skin, which was precisely why Cao Cao thought of sending Cao Hong.
First, as Cao Cao's cousin, even if Zang Ba could not come to terms with Cao Hong, he would have to think twice before executing him. After all, killing an ordinary envoy was one thing, but executing the cousin of the Governor of Yanzhou meant preparing to face Cao Cao's desperate, all-out retaliation. When all was said and done, Cao Cao's formidable reputation in Yanzhou was known to all.
Second, like Cao Cao, Cao Hong came from a distinguished family; his own paternal uncle was the Administrator of Wu Commandery, and they shared the same grandfather. In an era that regarded status and lineage as life itself, even a rebel leader would feel a sense of prestige upon receiving a visit from a scion of such a renowned family like Cao Hong. This would undoubtedly convince Zang Ba of Cao Cao's utmost sincerity.
Third, among all those bearing the surname Cao, Cao Hong's martial prowess was presently second to none. Since Zang Ba was a bandit leader, he was naturally a martial man forged in actual combat; such individuals invariably admired those with superior martial arts—a mutual appreciation of kindred spirits. Furthermore, Cao Cao believed that Cao Hong was experienced in business and possessed a silver tongue, making him the absolute best choice to lobby Zang Ba.
Realizing these three points, Cao Hong naturally did not suspect that Cao Cao was leading him into a fiery pit, but rather burned with the urgent hope and belief that he could accomplish this mission. Thus, having no reason to refuse, he asked, "What reasons should your younger brother use to persuade Zang Ba to serve our cause? If he agrees to work for us, what should we have him do?"
Cao Cao smiled and said, "The Qingzhou and Xuzhou Yellow Turban rebel forces were defeated by our army, leaving behind vast quantities of grain, heavy supplies, farming tools, and livestock. These were their only material assets in Yanzhou, and now that they are lost, they can only retreat back to Qingzhou or even Xuzhou to recuperate. To return to Qingzhou and Xuzhou, they must pass through Mount Tai Commandery. Your brother wants Zang Ba to dispatch troops to intercept them, after which I will issue a letter urging their surrender—nothing more! As for how to persuade Zang Ba, it boils down to a single word: Profit!"
Everyone understood the principle that no one stirs without the prospect of profit, but if Zang Ba were to help the Cao army, where lay the profit? Cao Hong could not fathom it and immediately voiced his inquiry.
Liu Ye, standing to the side, smiled and said, "Over the past ten days, I have sent men to infiltrate Mount Tai to investigate Zang Ba. This man is a native of Mount Tai. In his youth, because his father broke the law and was imprisoned, he gathered close friends, slew the guards, and rescued his father. Afterwards, he wandered everywhere. Because he was generous, bold, and possessed a heroic spirit, and because his act of saving his father won the respect of the local villagers, he gathered a band of rural righteous men and roamed the Mount Tai region.
"Several years later, when the Yellow Turban Rebellion broke out, he led his subordinates to surrender to Tao Qian, the Inspector of Xuzhou. Tao Qian appointed him as a Cavalry Commandant to resist the Yellow Turban rebels. A year later, when the Yellow Turbans were crushed, this man returned to Mount Tai, attempting to build an independent army and carve out his own sphere of influence. However, Tao Qian was unwilling to allow this and ordered him to hand over his subordinates. Isolated and weak in Xuzhou, Zang Ba had no choice but to flee back to Mount Tai Commandery by night, only to be pursued by Tao Qian from behind. Furthermore, as he passed through the neighboring Kingdom of Langye on the border of Mount Tai, he was ambushed by the then Chancellor of Langye, Xiao Tan, suffering heavy losses. Upon returning to Mount Tai, he was not tolerated by the local aristocratic clans and was thus forced to degenerate into a bandit, hiding deep within Mount Tai.
"This man bears an irreconcilable blood feud against Tao Qian and holds a deep grievance against Xiao Tan, the Chancellor of Langye. If you ask where the profit comes from, it comes precisely from this!"
Cao Hong had an epiphany and said, "So Elder Brother intends that as long as Zang Ba helps Elder Brother block the retreat route of the Qingzhou and Xuzhou Yellow Turbans, Elder Brother will help this man attack the Kingdom of Langye?"
Cao Cao laughed and said, "Precisely!"
Cao Hong mused, "Doing this might provoke the enmity of Tao Qian."
Cao Cao smiled and said, "How is that difficult? We simply need to supply grain, weapons, and siege equipment to Zang Ba, having unrelated third parties handle the transactions through resale, creating the appearance of open and honest commercial trade, while in reality not charging him a single copper coin. How would Tao Qian ever find out?"
Hearing this, Cao Hong chuckled and said, "Now that is a good idea!"
Cao Cao instructed, "On this trip to lobby Zang Ba, Zilian, you must act in secret. It is best not to take a single retainer, carrying only my personal letters."
Cao Hong nodded and agreed, "It should indeed be so! Rest assured, Elder Brother, with my martial skills, traveling alone will present no problem."
If the king of mercenaries were to be butchered halfway by a band of mountain bandits, that truly would be laughable.
Cao Cao smiled, "Your brother has absolute faith! However, Zilian will not be entirely isolated. Currently, my father is still in Huaxian County within Mount Tai Commandery, enjoying his twilight years. There are still several major clans in Huaxian that rely on able-bodied men to fend off bandits, retaining enough strength to protect themselves and remaining unfallen. As it happens, Zang Ba is a native of that very Huaxian. Therefore, Jiuyang also speculates that the Qingzhou and Xuzhou Yellow Turbans dared not advance into Huaxian precisely because Zang Ba was lurking nearby like a tiger eyeing its prey; moreover, when the Qingzhou and Xuzhou Yellow Turbans entered Mount Tai Commandery, Zang Ba did not trouble them either. The reason we recently received intelligence on Zang Ba is that when I sent men to Huaxian to gather information, they were received and guided by my father."
That bandits might reach a mutual understanding was not impossible, but the revelation that Cao Cao's elderly father, Cao Cao's father Cao Song, was retiring in Huaxian caught Cao Hong quite by surprise. The memory and knowledge of his original self only stated that Cao Song was living in seclusion in Mount Tai Commandery without specifying the exact location. In history, Cao Song died on his way to join Cao Cao, killed by none other than Tao Qian. Since Mount Tai lay within Yanzhou territory—meaning Cao Cao's own domain—how managed Tao Qian of Xuzhou to murder Cao Song? Was there something fishy going on in between?
Recalling the way Cao Cao controlled Dongjun, Cao Hong instantly understood. If fifteen counties in Dongjun could not even be fully garrisoned with his own soldiers, let alone the entirety of Yanzhou? Mount Tai bordered Xuzhou; it would be far too easy for Tao Qian to dispatch a group of assassins to slip across and murder Cao Cao's father. In ancient times, every three steps brought you to a forest, and every five steps to a hill; border regions between commanderies were virtually impossible to fortify. Sending a hundred or eighty men across to kill and burn was a simple task.
Yet why would Tao Qian want to kill Cao Song? Could it truly be as the *Romance of the Three Kingdoms* claimed—that a subordinate was greedy for wealth and acted without Tao Qian's knowledge? Cao Hong found that hard to believe. *Romance of the Three Kingdoms* had adapted far too much history, yet real history was not necessarily crystal clear in every detail either.
History did not record that Cao Cao sent Cao Hong to persuade Zang Ba to help, nor did it record that Zang Ba fell out with Tao Qian. However, it did record that Zang Ba stationed his troops in Kaiyang, which was the seat of government for the Kingdom of Langye. Furthermore, in the second year of Jian'an, namely 197 AD, he defeated Xiao Jian, the Chancellor of Langye. The current chancellor was named Xiao Tan; since both shared the surname Xiao, it was clear there was definitely some connection there.
Coupled with the fact that when Cao Cao later attacked Lü Bu, Zang Ba turned to assist Lü Bu, it showed that for a period of time Cao Cao and Zang Ba did not get along very well. Yet in the end, after Lü Bu's defeat, Cao Cao specifically named Zang Ba for capture, treated him generously upon his capture, released him, and continued to let him garrison the borderlands between Qingzhou, Xuzhou, and Yanzhou, even entrusting him with vital responsibilities during the campaign against Yuan Shao to defend against Yuan's forces in Qingzhou. The underlying reasons for all this were never fully explained in history.
However, if one factored in Cao Hong lobbying Zang Ba to help Cao Cao absorb the Qingzhou and Xuzhou Yellow Turbans, and Cao Cao subsidizing Zang Ba to attack Tao Qian's territory of Langye, everything suddenly made complete sense.
If Tao Qian truly had murdered Cao Cao's father, it would undoubtedly have been a retaliatory act, born of the moment he discovered Cao Cao was helping Zang Ba attack Langye. The present year was 192 AD, and Cao Song died in 193 AD—the timing matched up without a single flaw. As a result, Cao Cao fell out with Zang Ba over this incident, though perhaps after coming to his senses later on, he ceased to blame Zang Ba and promptly re-employed him.
After sorting through history and reality, Cao Hong seemed to piece together the trajectory of the events about to transpire between Cao Cao, Zang Ba, and Tao Qian.
Yet Cao Cao was merely supplying materials to Zang Ba through third-party intermediaries. Logically speaking, this should have been foolproof, so why would Tao Qian find out?
*'How utterly bizarre! I wonder if I can uncover any clues when I go to lobby Zang Ba this time!'* Cao Hong pondered inwardly, while aloud he tentatively asked Cao Cao, "Now that Elder Brother has essentially secured a firm foothold in Yanzhou, might it be time to invite our eldest uncle over?"
If Cao Song could come to Cao Cao's side now, wouldn't he be able to escape this calamity? After Cao Song's death, a furious Cao Cao immediately launched an expedition against Yanzhou—no, Xuzhou—sending Tao Qian into a dizzying panic, brutally slaughtering several cities in the process, and ultimately drawing Liu Bei into the fray to camp right at the Cao army's rear for a long spell. As a result, Lü Bu and Chen Gong along with Zhang Miao seized the opportunity to launch a surprise attack on Yanzhou, leaving Cao Cao nearly homeless, while Xuzhou itself was not captured by Cao Cao until the eve of the Battle of Guandu. Thus, this was unquestionably a rather unsuccessful military operation; as a general in the Cao camp, Cao Hong naturally hoped for total victory every single time.
Since it could be avoided, he had to put his heart into it, which was why Cao Hong spoke up. But Cao Cao merely smiled and said, "I have not assumed the post of Governor of Yanzhou for long, and with this million-plus Qingzhou and Xuzhou Yellow Turbans yet to be absorbed, our strength is still insufficient to overawe the various factions throughout Yanzhou. Therefore, this is not the time to have our father join us. For now, he is getting along quite harmoniously with several local gentry families in Huaxian, and no doubt has spent a fair amount of wealth. By comparison, Huaxian is much more secure."
Hearing this, Cao Hong nodded and said, "Elder Brother is right!" *Sigh!* It seemed this plan to pull the firewood from under the cauldron would not work; he could only go to Huaxian to see if he could discover any clues, Cao Hong mused silently to himself.
He was one hundred percent certain that news of the transactions between Cao Cao and Zang Ba must have leaked, allowing Tao Qian to find out, which was why Tao Qian threw caution to the wind and murdered Cao Cao's father to vent his spleen. Otherwise, how could Tao Qian—a man who shrank back and ignored major events like the campaign against Dong Shao—have acted with such madness and lack of reason?
Since Cao Cao had no intention of welcoming Cao Song beforehand, the problem had to be solved at its root. If possible... that was what Cao Hong was thinking in his heart.
Seeing that official matters had been concluded, Cao Cao smiled and said, "Since that is settled, Zilian, you should set off as soon as possible."
Cao Hong cupped his fists and said, "Understood!" With that, he took his leave and departed.